Skip to main content

A Perfect King or an Imperfect Husband?

Recently on social media, I found many debates rising on Ram's decisions as a King and a Husband. Did his Dharma as a King overshadow his Dharma as a husband? Did he love and respect his partner? Where was Sita in all of this?

Ram: The King Who Became a God

The ancient Valmiki Ramayana depicts Ram as a mortal king, a ruler of Ayodhya whose deeds and adherence to dharma elevated him to divine stature. Later texts, especially after Tulsidas’s Ramcharitmanas, revere him as an incarnation of Vishnu, the divine preserver, descended to restore righteousness on Earth. This article considers Ram primarily as a king, a human whose life illuminates the ideal of rulership through action, duty, and sacrifice.
In Hindu philosophy, every life is believed to possess a purpose. While most individuals spend their years seeking it, a few rare souls, mahapurushas, recognise their purpose from childhood and dedicate themselves entirely to it. Ram was one such being.

The Context of Treta Yug

Ram was born during the Treta Yug, the second age in the cycle of four Yugas. In that era, northern India was governed by noble kingdoms, while the southern forests were inhabited by asuras and rakshasas. Farther south lay Lanka, ruled by Ravan, the powerful and arrogant Rakshasa king.
Ravan had besieged Lanka from his half-brother, Kuber, the god of wealth, who fled north-east to establish the city of Alanka. Though Ravan was a devout follower of Lord Shiva and a scholar of immense learning, his vanity and desire for immortality corrupted him. His tyranny burdened his subjects, who were punished harshly even for minor faults. He kept slaves and exploited the poor. Witnessing Ravan’s success through adharma, many kings across Aryavarta began to follow his path of greed and cruelty.
Ram’s birth was destined to restore balance. He came to demonstrate what an ideal king should be to uphold Kshatriya dharma and preserve righteous kingship. Yet, in contrast to the hunger for power that consumed others, Ram showed detachment even as a young prince.
When the time came to ascend the throne, Ram instead chose exile, honouring the promise his father Dasharatha had made to Queen Kaikeyi. He renounced the kingdom, saying, “I wish to see what greatness lies in the throne that Mother Kaikeyi covets so deeply, and what fear dwells in the forest that Mother Kausalya dreads.” Fourteen years later, when destiny returned him to Ayodhya, he accepted the throne but not for power’s sake. Some wonder why he then chose the throne over his beloved wife. Had he fought the world to save Sita only to abandon her for his kingdom?

Ram and Sita: The Ideal Companions

Many modern critics view Ram as an imperfect husband, too bound to duty, too distant from Sita. Yet, accounts of their marriage suggest otherwise. Soon after their wedding, in Queen Kausalya’s courtyard, they shared a conversation that revealed Ram’s understanding of marriage and kingship.
Sita asked him, “If Queen Kaikeyi is your father’s favourite, then what is your mother’s place in his heart?”
Ram replied, “A king has many queens but only one wife. Kaikeyi may be his favourite queen, but my mother is his wife.”
“What then,” Sita asked, “is the difference between a wife and a queen?”
He answered, “A queen is the mother of the subjects; a wife is the mother of his children. A queen rules beside him; a wife lives with him.”
Then Ram promised her, “You will always be both, my wife and my queen.”
He kept that promise. Tempted by none, not even the beautiful Shurpanakha, he remained devoted only to Sita. In the age and time the story happens, it was neither frowned upon nor scrutinised for a king to have more than one wife, yet the Ramayana does not record any of the four brothers having more than one wife, honouring the cultural belief of the land the wives came from, the kingdom of Mithila. Ram waged war against Ravan with limited weapons and an army of forest dwellers, risking even his brother’s life to rescue her. In every sense, Ram embodied the ideal husband, and Sita, the ideal wife.
During her captivity in Lanka, surrounded by Ravan’s mistresses who urged her to surrender, Sita held fast to her virtue. She rejected every luxury offered to her and lived in simplicity, her heart anchored in her husband’s faith. Later, at Valmiki’s hermitage, she raised their twins, Luv and Kush, in isolation but with dignity and strength.

The Test of the Ideal King

Meanwhile, in Ayodhya, Ram’s younger brother Bharat faced a moral dilemma in ruling. Though Kaikeyi desired his ascension, Bharat refused to sit upon the throne meant for Ram. Instead, he placed Ram’s sandals upon the royal seat and governed as his representative for fourteen years.
When Ram returned from exile, the kingdom rejoiced, and he was crowned at last. As king of the solar dynasty, Suryavansha, Ram saw himself as the father of his subjects. His duty toward his people came before personal happiness. His father’s generation had failed that test; Dasharatha’s promises to his queen had deprived his people of their rightful ruler for over a decade. Ram was determined not to repeat that mistake.
When rumours regarding Sita’s chastity spread among the citizens, sparked by the words of a dhobi, Ram faced his greatest moral crisis. His heart knew the truth of her purity, but his role as king demanded impartiality. Choosing his personal feelings over his public duties would have betrayed the very dharma he was born to protect. Reluctantly, he ordered Sita to leave Ayodhya. It was not a lack of trust but a painful duty.
Sita, understanding his turmoil, accepted her fate without protest. She never resented him, though later, in wounded dignity, she withheld news of their sons until their fateful reunion ten years later.

Eternal Companions

Hindu tradition honours Sita as the embodiment of endurance, purity, and strength. Through her trials, the scriptures reveal society’s harsh judgment of women and her quiet defiance against it. Though the world questioned her, posterity worships her as a goddess who stands beside Ram as his eternal equal.

The Legacy of Sacrifice

Ram had a choice. He could have chosen Sita, lived a peaceful life, and seen his children and grandchildren grow. But he chose his subjects instead. In doing so, he sacrificed personal happiness for the greater good. His sacrifice made him immortal in the hearts of his people. Indeed, it is not merely devotion that deifies Ram; it is his unwavering sense of duty, his compassion, and his readiness to place the common good above self. Sita’s faith, paired with his sacrifice, transformed them both into symbols of eternal virtue. Their union of love and duty, loss and divinity, continues to define what it means to live for something greater than oneself, a lesson that has endured from the Treta Yug to our own times.

Sita’s Side of the Story

Every story, like a coin, has two sides. One cannot exist without the other. The tale of Ram and the exile of Sita also bears two truths. Until now, the narrative has been understood primarily through the perspective of Ram, his Dharma, and his duties as a righteous king. Yet hidden between the unspoken lines of this vast epic lies another story: that of Sita, who endures suffering with patience and unyielding dignity.

Sita, who defined chastity and courage, refused every luxury Ravana offered her during her captivity. She waited steadfastly for her husband’s rescue and, once freed, willingly walked through the fire to prove her purity. She did not question Ram then, for she understood the customs of her time, the need to demonstrate chastity to a society that doubted any woman who had lived apart from her husband. Her trial by fire was both a testament to her faith and a reflection of the patriarchal structure that bound even divine figures.

After fourteen years of hardship and sacrifice, Sita finally returned to Ayodhya, restored as the rightful queen. Yet the grandeur of her welcome concealed signs of a future tragedy. Her only misstep was a human one; she spoke of Lanka and her time there. She shared how she befriended the women who guarded her and told them stories of the knowledge and valour of Lanka, its culture and people, including the might of Ravana. Sita’s intention had been innocent and educational as she wished to enlighten the women of Ayodhya, who seldom ventured beyond palace walls.

At last, she was content. She was soon to become the mother of the heir to Ayodhya’s throne, her face glowing with peace of expectancy. Her love for Ram remained as strong as ever, and all she wanted now was the same honesty and trust from the husband she revered as both man and king. But fate intervened. Ram’s first grave error was not in doubting her but abandoning her without explanation. Sita was left in the forest, unaware of her supposed crime. She had been as much a subject of Ayodhya as any other citizen, yet justice evaded her, just as it had in Lanka. Alone and confused, she endured the wilderness, forsaken by the one she trusted most, promising to show her child the light of day.

The Woman Who Endured

In the forest, Sita’s resilience shone brighter than ever. She sought no pity, nor did she resign herself to despair. Her strength guided her to the sage Valmiki, where she found shelter and purpose. Soon, she gave birth to twins, Luv and Kush. As a single mother, Sita vowed not to reveal the truth of their parentage, choosing silence over bitterness. The societal accusations against her chastity had cast doubt upon the legitimacy of Ayodhya’s heirs, too. To protect her sons and their dignity, she decided they would grow up without the knowledge of their father’s rejection.

Sita’s decision was revolutionary for her time. She refused to subject her children to a world that had condemned her. It was an act of agency and self-respect, virtues often denied to women of her age. She raised the boys with moral strength, courage, and wisdom, preparing them unknowingly for the moment destiny would reunite them with Ram.

A decade later, fate brought the family together again. Luv and Kush’s true identity was revealed, and the citizens of Ayodhya repented for their earlier harshness. Yet their realisation came not out of moral awakening but pragmatic acceptance; they saw in the twins the continuation of the Suryavansha, the solar dynasty. Once again, Sita was summoned to return to Ayodhya, now as the mother of the rightful heirs.

She agreed to part with her sons for the sake of duty, willing to sacrifice her motherhood for the greater good of the kingdom. But her return reignited the same agony. The court demanded that she once more affirm her purity. Again, her devotion as a wife and her sacrifice as a mother were eclipsed by public suspicion.


The Final Stand

Sita had reached the end of endurance. Betrayed not once, but twice by society, by family, and by the man she called her own, she voiced her final defiance. Her last moments were not marked by quiet forgiveness but by righteous anger. She questioned the world that had glorified her yet abandoned her, the people who revered her as a goddess yet failed her as a woman, and the husband who professed love but surrendered to royal duty.

Her words carried the unspoken truth that echoed through centuries: perhaps a perfect king was not a perfect husband. Many of the epic’s countless versions, spanning over 2,500 languages and 300 narratives, record her lament that no Dharma could justify such pain.

In the end, the righteousness (Dharma) Ram upheld was not universal. It failed to account for human love and fairness. It sanctified sacrifice but ignored suffering. It produced an ideal king but not an ideal man.

Ram’s greatness as ruler rested on his sacrifice, his willingness to forsake personal happiness for his kingdom. But measured as a husband and father, he will always be questioned. Sita, by contrast, embodied strength through endurance, maintaining faith and dignity even when the world was not kind.

Their union stands as the most profound contradiction in Hindu mythology: the divine pair whose love was eternal yet unequal, whose devotion endured beyond justice itself.

Sita’s suffering and Ram’s sacrifice together defined the age of Treta Yug, a reminder that divinity, duty, and humanity do not always align. The epic does not ask us to choose sides but to understand both: the god who became a king, and the woman who remained divine despite being wronged.




Devdutt Pattnaik's Illustrations on Sita





Popular posts from this blog

Rakhi Tales

The year was 1535 CE. The Rajmata of Mewar, widow of Rana Sanga, was in a dilemma. On one hand was an attack from Bahadur Shah of Gujarat as a threat to her capital, Chittorgarh, and the throne of her beloved teenage son Vikramaditya. On the other hand, there was the son of her husband's archenemy, Humayun, who could be of some help. Rani Karnavati wrote a letter to Humayun, who was in the east at that time. Along with it, she sent a Rakhi, a thread of brotherhood, asking him, as a sister, for protection against the enemy. But the road was too long and time, of great essence. Humayun arrived at Chittorgarh, in response to her letter, keeping his end of the bargain but a little late. Rani Karnavati had already performed the Jauhar. They never met. Humayun established Rana Vikramaditya on the throne of Mewar, as he had promised as a brother, and returned to his post. Two dynasties, political rivals and sworn enemies, from Sanga-Babur to Pratap-Akbar and even Raj Singh-Aurangzeb, yet ...

A Veranda Vendetta

  “Outrage in Calcutta; Terrorist Raid, British Officer Murdered”   Read the headlines of The Times on Tuesday, 9 th  of December, 1930.   1930: A significant year 1930 was a very significant year in the history of India’s Freedom Struggle against the British Raj. The Indian National Congress went ahead to declare the 26 th  of January as India’s Independence Day, celebrating it nationwide; the Civil Disobedience Movement was officially started by Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, and Subhas Chandra Bose was arrested for participating in the same. On 18 th  April, Surya Sen, better known as MasterDa, had done the unthinkable, raiding the British Armoury with his students and fellow teachers at Chittagong. He was still on the loose, yet to be found.  In this year of growing protests against the colonisers, an incident emerged that shook the British at their old capital. The Bengal Volunteers Corps was a group of volunteers organised in the 1928 Calcutta sessi...

Bijolia: Her Home

Journey to Bijolia: Lost Kingdoms and Timeless Temples of Mewar Bijoliya translates to a stop between two cities. Nestled in Rajasthan’s Bhilwara district, Bijolia sits 55km from Bundi and 105km from Chittorgarh on the well-travelled Bundi-Chittorgarh road. Once part of Mewar, this seemingly sleepy town guards a rich and layered past: it was ruled from the 11th to the 13th century by the Punwars (or Parmar Rajputs) before falling under the Chauhan dynasty, who shifted the region’s capital to Bhilwara and constructed the imposing fort there. After a brief Chauhan rule, Bijolia was reclaimed by Rana Kumbha and became an integral part of the Mewar kingdom, with the Parmars serving as local Raos, representatives and stewards of the royal house. Despite its history and the famed Bijolia inscriptions (a treasure for historians), Bijolia has never found a seat on Rajasthan’s primary tourist circuit, especially if you’re venturing out by public transport or private car. While a handful of...

A Journey Called PrAja

Love is a relationship based on trust and understanding.  It is also a bond that is made up there. People often ask, "Why them?" I end up telling them some folklore. I end up telling them about how she actually was his shadow in the forests, in bad times. Because love passes all its tests in the worst times when you don't give up on each other. So, here's to My Pratap and His Ajabdeh! Ps. This is about the show Bharat Ka Veer Putra Maharana Pratap on Sony by Contilloe Starring Faisal Khan, Roshni Walia, Sharad Malhotra and Rachana Parulkar. This is NOT their real story. The show aired from 2013 to 2015. Ajabdeh, the simple, strong yet gentle samantputri, was starstruck seeing the down-to-earth Kunwar Pratap, the crown prince of Mewar. She was clueless that he held the key to her heart, her lost mala that destiny had chosen him for.  Na na na na na Chan Chan Chan Chan na na na na! A comedy of errors followed, as she threw the pail of water on him, fumbled at his presen...

The Hidden One

In the grand fort of Daulatabad, a princess was born in 1638 to Emperor Aurangzeb and his cherished consort, Dilras Banu Begum. She was christened Zeb Un Nisa, her very name meaning “ornament of womankind.” The youngest of her sisters, Zeb Un Nisa, grew up surrounded by the opulence of the Mughal harem at the Red Fort, under the spiritual guidance of her Sufi uncle Dara Shikoh and her wise aunt Jahanara Begum. From her earliest days, she was captivated by poetry, spending hours immersed in literature, her mind dancing among the verses of Persian and Urdu poets. As she blossomed into adulthood, Zeb Un Nisa cultivated her own literary voice and gathered the greatest poets of the Mughal Empire in her private council. Adopting the pen name “Makhfi”, the Concealed One, she wove magic with her words, always returning to one intoxicating theme: Love. Her father, Emperor Aurangzeb, was the most powerful man in India, unyielding in his faith and rule, yet also deeply affectionate towards his ...

The Emperor's First Wife

  Ruqaiya Sultana Begum  was born to Babur's second surviving son, Hindal Mirza, and his wife, Sultanam Begum, in 1542 C.E., merely a few months after Hamida Banu gave birth to the heir Jalaluddin Mohammad Akbar. She was well-versed in Persian, Urdu and Arabic and was attracted to poetry and music. Being a proud descendant of the Timurid clan, most of Rukaiya's childhood was spent in Kabul, near the Bagh E Babur, built by Babur himself. From early childhood, she had seen the struggle of her family to regain their lost power in Hind. In 1551 C.E., just after her father died young at a battle for Humayun, leaving her and her mother in the harem of the emperor, it was Hamida Banu who wanted the marriage of Rukaiya to her first cousin, Akbar. Theirs was the first in-house marriage of the Mughals, soon to be followed by many more in the generations to come. At the mere age of nine, she had married the crown prince, and when Humayun won back Lahore, she was fifteen. At the mere age ...

Sisodiya: Kings, Queens and Princes (1538 - 1597)

I am back with another History post, this time it is on the wives and sons of Rana Udai Singh II of Mewar, his son and heir Maharana Pratap and Rana Amar Singh. This is a continuation of the Sisodia Family History I posted some time back. The information has been taken from Annals of Mewar by James Todd, Maharana Pratap by B.N. Rana, and Maharana Pratap by Rima Hooja.  Udai Singh II  was the son of Ranisa Karnawati and Rana Sangram Singh. He was born on 4th August 1 522, at Chittorgarh and died on 28th February 1 572 at Gogunda . He was the Ruler of the Sisodia Dynasty. He is believed to have  56 sons and 2 5 wives, apart from the many insignificant queens in his Rani Mahal. Here is a list of his main queens and their sons. Maharani Jaivanta Bai Songara of Jalore  was his chief queen and consort. Her son is Maharana Pratap. He was married to her before he went to war with Banbir, as her father, Akshayraj Rao, was a friend and ally of his father, Rana Sanga.  Saj...

Mewar: Parting Words

The journey through Mesmerising Mewar ended the night I boarded my train from Udaipur, my heart weighed down by the memories I was leaving behind. As the city lights shimmered in the darkness, I found myself turning back at every chance, reluctant to bid farewell to Mewar, a place that felt less like a travel destination and more like a forgotten home. Sometimes I wonder if my love for the place comes from another life. My parents certainly think so. With the city’s silhouette fading behind me, it felt only right to share my last thoughts: the flavours of the cities, the hills of Aravallis, the moments that made those 15 days feel like a dream, a dream I had dreamt a long time ago, to see his world, through his eyes. His home.  I’ll be forever grateful for. The Food: Soul of Mewar Udaipur is a feast in every sense! I dove headfirst into plates brimming with local aloo sabzi, peas cooked with a gentle sweetness, and the signature Rajasthani Churma that seemed to melt away any tra...

A Chivalrous Emnity

“Ranisa. Hukum” There was a hint of urgency in the maid in waiting’s voice as she rushed to the clearing where the tents were set up. Rani Pur Bai Solanki, the second queen, frowned at her sudden, alarming voice. “Hush, Rama, the children are...” She checked the children’s tent, alarmed. They slept during the day and stayed awake at night, because the forestland was not safe, neither from animals nor the enemies. “Ranisa, forgive me, it's Kunwarsa... He is back... but...” Pur Bai’s face lit up with a smile of hope that didn’t last long. “But?” “What is it? What’s wrong?” The Maharani of Mewar had walked out of her camp, with the other queens in tow. The maid bowed before her. “It’s Kunwarsa.” “He is back?” She frowned. He was not supposed to be back so early until his father reached Dholan. “So is Ranaji.” The maid looked scared. “There is a court called in an emergency. I came to inform you that Ranaji wanted everyone to be present.” “Jija...” Pur Bai could see the tension mountin...

Mystic Murshidabad

Discovering Murshidabad: A Weekend in Bengal’s Royal Past A mere 200km from the heart of Kolkata, nestled in the historical district of Murshidabad, West Bengal, I set off for a weekend steeped in stories and grandeur. Before sharing the trip’s highlights, let me give you a quick primer on this fascinating place. Murshidabad: Where Bengal’s Destiny Changed Murshidabad, once an obscure village called Maksudabad, was transformed in 1704 when Murshid Quli Khan, Aurangzeb’s formidable general, shifted the capital of Subah Bangla from Dhaka to this very spot. The move not only brought prestige but also changed the fate of the Bengal province, stretching across present-day West Bengal, Odisha, Bihar, Jharkhand, and Bangladesh. The town was renamed after its patron, and by 1716, Murshid Quli Khan was crowned Nawab of Bengal by the Mughal Emperor. The region’s influence soon encompassed what are now the districts of Nadia and Murshidabad. Berhampore: The Modern Gateway Today, the district...