Skip to main content

Jodha Bai: A Fact Check on Mughal History

 

In popular culture


Jodha Bai, as we know her, is the title by which we refer more often to the Rajput wife of Emperor Jalaluddin Mohammad Akbar, the third Emperor of the Mughal (originally Timurid) dynasty who ruled between 1556 and 1605 A.D. She appears in various folklores of the popular "Akbar Birbal stories for Children '' as a queen, and these fictional tales on the wit of Birbal often are in fact our first introduction to both Akbar and Jodha Bai as children. These folktales have been taken up by various animators to be made into series. India's most popular platform of entertainment, besides its cricket, is Bollywood and Hindi cinema.


One of the most iconic movies ever made in the industry is "Mughal-e-Azam", which revolves around yet another fictitious tale of Prince Salim, later Jahangir, falling for a dancing girl from his father's harem, Anarkali. There, we see Prithviraj Kapoor in his iconic voice as Akbar, referring to his queen and Salim's mother as Jodha as well. Skip to Ashutosh Gowariker's most popular historical movie so far, the 2008 Hritik-Aishwarya starrer "Jodha Akbar" Yet again, the Rajput princess from Amer has been addressed as Jodha Bai. This movie inspired the later Zee TV drama called "Jodha Akbar" by the television star producer Ekta Kapoor, where yet again she has been portrayed as his love and the chief queen.



Who should be referred to as Jodha Bai?


The princesses who hail from Marwar, presently Jodhpur, Mehrangarh Fort or any other place belonging to the Marwar Rathore rulers were actually addressed as Jodha Bai or Jodh Bai. That can also include Merta Princesses, the most popular one being Meera Bai, who was married to Bhoj Raj, the heir apparent of Rana Sanga of Chittorgarh, Mewar.


Was Akbar's wife Jodha Bai?


Akbar married not one but many Rajput princesses under his alliance policy. He may have had princesses from Marwar in his harem as well. (Harem being where the women, including royals and their staff, stayed) But the princess of Amer, who is referred to as Jodha Bai, was not actually someone with that title. The title had, over time, been wrongly attributed to her. She is Harka Bai, born to Raja Bharmal of Amer and is also referred to as Heer Kanwar. Her date of birth remains unknown, as is the case with most Rajput women of her time, but her lineage is in no way related to the Rathores of Marwar. She came into Akbar's Harem after a marriage of Alliance between Amer and the Timurids. Akbar by then had two chief wives. His chief wife, cousin and consort, Rukaiya Sultana Begum, the daughter of his father's half-brother Hindal Mirza and Salima Sultana Begum, the daughter of his father's sister, who also happened to be a widow of his mentor Bairam Khan, who died in an attack. 


Harka Bai was prominent in establishing Akbar as a secular ruler and contributed to history by incorporating her Rajput culture and heritage into the Timurid legacy. She, along with other princesses who came from different Hindu states, made the Rajput Harem, which she in turn headed. She was not his Padshah Begum. She was the head of the Rajput Harem. Rukaiya remained Akbar's Padshah Begum throughout her life. The only reason Harka Bai finds more mention in Akbar's self-sponsored Biography by Abul Fazl, the Akbarnama, is that she had given birth to his first heir, Salim, after much difficulty in Akbar's life for an heir apparent. 


Upon Salim's birth, she was given the title of "Mariam Ur Zamani" or Mary of the Age. She lived well into her son's reign, had her own trading ships and business dealings and died in 1623 A.D. In Jahangir's own memorial, Tuzk E Jahangiri, he fondly remembers her by her title, Mariam Ur Zamani.




This scene from "Akbarnama" depicts the birth of Salim and Mariam Ur Zamani is shown on the bed, her complexion clearly more subcontinental than the Timurid ladies. This is perhaps the most detailed painting found of her alongside Hamida Banu Begum, Akbar's mother, who is seen (not in this part) in the painting wearing a Turkish hat. Salim was born in Sikri, a few miles from Agra, at the house of Salim Chisti, one of the descendants of the founder of the Chisti order of Sufism, Moinuddin Chisti, whose shrine is at Ajmer.


Was there any Jodha Bai?


The most popular princess in the Mughal(Timurid) Harem, who was probably originally referred to as Jodha Bai or Jodha Begum, could be Salim's wife, Manwati Kanwar, the second Rajput princess Salim married. She was the daughter of Raja Udai Singh Rathore, better known as Mota Raja and granddaughter of Rao Maldeo Rathore of Marwar (Jodhpur).

She is better known as the mother of Prince Khurram, the later emperor Shah Jahan.


The prince Khurram was handed over to Akbar's first wife, Rukaiya Begum, whom he fondly called "Shah Ammi." Manwati's official royal title was "Jagat Gossain", and she was perhaps the closest contender to Nur Jahan to be Jahangir's consort. She died early, during the reign of Jahangir in 1619. She is remembered in his memoirs and has been clearly referred to as the Jodhpuri princess in various sources. Her residence was at the Jahangir Mahal of Agra Fort. 


Jagat Gossain



Fact check on popular culture:


A lot of our beliefs and knowledge actually come from popular media such as stories and movies, rather than facts. Here are a few popular facts that have been wrongly incorporated into our lives on the Mughals, as well as perhaps even in our history books. (I will add points here as I progress, so your inputs are welcome, with sources)


  1. The dynasty is called the Timurids. They hail from Timur the Lame, and their native place was Samarkand. The popular name Mughal was given to them by Europeans to reflect upon Babar's maternal side, hailing from Genghis Khan and the Mongols, who were often referred to as Barbaric. It was a futile attempt to make the dynasty look bad.

  2. The Baburnama is not original. The original accounts written by Babar were lost, and the recreated version has 8 different sources written over a long period in different versions post his death.

  3. The Humayun Nama, written by his half-sister Gulbadan Begum, under the patronage of Akbar, has been found in pieces. The rest of it remains missing.

  4. Jalaluddin Mohammad Akbar was one of the first rulers to speak up against child marriage and Sati. 

  5. Anarkali is fiction. The entire story had been written later by a poet. However, some say there was a dancer girl called Nadira whom Salim took an interest in, causing a rift between him and his father, in a futile attempt to get back at his father. Salim, later Jahangir, throughout his life, acknowledged his love for his later wife, Nur Jahan.

  6. Shah Jahan built the Taj Mahal on a property gifted by Raja Jagat Singh for his second official wife, Arjumand Banu Begum, Mumtaj Mahal, the mother of his children. He did not marry any of her relatives or her sister. His other chief Begums were Qandahari Begum (From Kandahar), Zainabadi Begum and Fatehpuri Begum.

  7. No outsiders were allowed into the inner zenanas of the Harem. Nor did they visit any princesses in person. Any attempt by Europeans claiming so is just bazaar gossip, including their theories of incest and affairs that pointed at the characters of the princesses, namely, Jahanara and Roshanara. Since these writers were sponsored by the courts of European kings, they cooked up these stories to please their patrons, mostly because they were intimidated by the power and freedom these princesses held

  8. Most think Aurangzeb was a cruel and unjust ruler. What they don't often know is that he was just like Shah Jahan. And ever since his mother's death, Shah Jahan was very partial toward his children. Dara got to sit on a golden throne after his defeat in Kandahar, while Aurangzeb was scrutinised over the smallest of details of whether he sent the emperor the good mangoes from his orchard or kept them for himself. (We will do that story some other time.)

  9. None of the wives belonging to any other religion was ever converted. The titles given to them were official honours and not a change of name. The mausoleums in their names were made in their honour, and they were not buried inside. The wives belonging to any other religion practised their own. Even Akbar or Jahangir followed certain rituals of Hinduism as well as Sufism. They were not devout Muslims, much like the later Prince Mohammad Dara Shikoh, son of Shah Jahan, who was perhaps the first one in the dynasty to officially embrace Sufism. 

  10. Most importantly, in conclusion, Jodha Bai was neither Akbar's first Rajput queen nor the mother of Salim. Akbar's Rajput queen was Harka Bai, and Salim's wife was Jodha Bai.


Bibliography:

These are some of the very basic starting books you can refer to.
  1. Akbar Nama

  2. Akbar The Great Mogul by Vincent Smith

  3. Tuzk E Jahangiri

  4. Short History of Aurangzeb by Jadunath Sircar

  5. Mughal Empire by R.C. Majumder

  6. Medieval India by Satish Chandra

  7. Empress by Ruby Lal

  8. Daughters of the Sun by Ira Mukhoty

  9. Mahal by Subhadra Sengupta

  10. Royal Rajputs by Manoshi Bhattacharya


Popular posts from this blog

Maharana Pratap: The Sun of Mewar

Many of you have read my fan fiction as well as historical representations of the life and times of Maharana Pratap Singh of Mewar. I provided small details of his life in many articles. But never have I ever made a separate historical post on him. It is very difficult to put together his life without the help of folklore because historical evidence is scarce. This one was requested, and hence here it goes. Needless to say, this one is very special. This is a blend of history and folklore. Leave your love.  ❤️ Background and Birth: The year was 1540. Mewar was under a cloud of uncertainty. Banbir, their ruler for four years now, was a very incompetent ruler who always spent his time in luxury, drinking and dancing with girls. The crown prince Udai Singh was rumoured to have been killed by him. Chittorgarh was in darkness. Around March 1540, Mewar once again saw hope as some trusted generals, along with Kunwar Udai Singh, attacked Chittorgarh, taking Banbir by surprise. He was soon ...

Bijolia: Her Home

Journey to Bijolia: Lost Kingdoms and Timeless Temples of Mewar Bijoliya translates to a stop between two cities. Nestled in Rajasthan’s Bhilwara district, Bijolia sits 55km from Bundi and 105km from Chittorgarh on the well-travelled Bundi-Chittorgarh road. Once part of Mewar, this seemingly sleepy town guards a rich and layered past: it was ruled from the 11th to the 13th century by the Punwars (or Parmar Rajputs) before falling under the Chauhan dynasty, who shifted the region’s capital to Bhilwara and constructed the imposing fort there. After a brief Chauhan rule, Bijolia was reclaimed by Rana Kumbha and became an integral part of the Mewar kingdom, with the Parmars serving as local Raos, representatives and stewards of the royal house. Despite its history and the famed Bijolia inscriptions (a treasure for historians), Bijolia has never found a seat on Rajasthan’s primary tourist circuit, especially if you’re venturing out by public transport or private car. While a handful of...

The Emperor's First Wife

  Ruqaiya Sultana Begum  was born to Babur's second surviving son, Hindal Mirza, and his wife, Sultanam Begum, in 1542 C.E., merely a few months after Hamida Banu gave birth to the heir Jalaluddin Mohammad Akbar. She was well-versed in Persian, Urdu and Arabic and was attracted to poetry and music. Being a proud descendant of the Timurid clan, most of Rukaiya's childhood was spent in Kabul, near the Bagh E Babur, built by Babur himself. From early childhood, she had seen the struggle of her family to regain their lost power in Hind. In 1551 C.E., just after her father died young at a battle for Humayun, leaving her and her mother in the harem of the emperor, it was Hamida Banu who wanted the marriage of Rukaiya to her first cousin, Akbar. Theirs was the first in-house marriage of the Mughals, soon to be followed by many more in the generations to come. At the mere age of nine, she had married the crown prince, and when Humayun won back Lahore, she was fifteen. At the mere age ...

The Buddhist Empress of India

Many historians believe that although Devi was the first wife of Asoka, his Buddhist queen, Asandhimitra, was not the same person. However, some also theorise based on Buddhist and Jain stories that they were in fact the same person, and the reason for that is that they don't seem to appear in the timeline together. Devi disappears when Asandhimitra arrives at the scene rather abruptly to do her charitable work. Hence, I personally believe they were one and the same. This story, however, is a retelling of folklore and not history. Please do not consider this piece of fiction as history. The whole village of Vidisha Nagari was buzzing with activity. Every home was being cleaned, and cooking preparations were on. The youngest prince of Magadha was coming to a halt the night at their village on his way to Ujjain. Great unrest was reported at Ujjain, and the youngest prince, as the general of this region, was being sent by the emperor to solve the issue. The villagers were scared as th...

Nawab E Bengal

  Background: Nawab Alivardi Khan was ruling Bengal at the peak of Nawabi rule, expanding his strong empire. He had successfully suppressed the Marathas and had given a strong message to the British East India Company’s rising influence at Calcutta. Highly aware of the British Colonial policies across the globe, Nawab Alivardi Khan was strict with his policies and stronghold over Murshidabad, the then capital of Bengal (including present-day Bihar, Jharkhand, West Bengal, Orissa, and Bangladesh).  He had two daughters and no sons. Amina Begum was the elder one, followed by Ghaseti Begum. Amina had three sons with her husband and courtier, Ahmed Khan. The second son, Mirza Mohammad, fondly called Siraj-Ud-Daulah (light of the country)by his grandfather, was born in 1733C.E. He was his grandfather’s  favourite  because he was born while he won over the Marathas. Alivardi Khan never let the “fortune child” of the family out of his sight. Siraj grew up accompanying his g...

Chittorgarh: The First Jauhar

The concept of Jauhar holds a profound place in Rajputana history. It is a ritual where Rajput women willingly choose death by jumping into a fire altar, invoking the gods, and embracing honour rather than living under the humiliation of enemy conquest. Unlike Sati, Jauhar was never forced or compulsory; it was considered the most honourable death a Rajputani could choose when their men lost battles and the enemy laid siege. The Historical Setting: Jauhar Gate and Chittorgarh Fort Chittorgarh Fort once housed the palace of Rana Ratan Singh near the famed Vijay Stambh and his Jal Mahal at the fort’s main gate. When Alauddin Khilji invaded Chittor, much of this was destroyed. However, later ruler Rana Kumbha rebuilt the Jal Mahal and re-established the Jauhar Sthal to honour Queen Padmavati (also known as Padmini). Ratan Singh, who ruled Mewar during Khilji’s reign as Sultan of Delhi, was known to be a peace-loving monarch who enjoyed music and poetry. One of his court poets, Ragha...

Chittorgarh: The Devoted Fort

Chittorgarh, renowned for its tales of sacrifice and valour, is also a remarkable testimony to secular harmony and religious heritage that flourished over centuries. Beyond battles and sieges, the fort and its surroundings are dotted with numerous temples, talabs (reservoirs), kunds (water tanks), and temple complexes;  some intact, others abandoned or in ruins, each narrating stories of devotion, culture, and royal patronage. The Legend of Meera Bai: Devotion and Defiance One of the most inspiring figures linked to Chittorgarh’s spiritual legacy is Meera Bai , the saint poetess and princess of Merta. Married in 1513 AD at age 14 to Maharaj Kumar  Bhoj Raj Singh Sisodiya , the eldest son of Rana Sanga, her story is one of profound devotion. As a child, Meera Bai was deeply attached to the idol of Lord Krishna, whom she considered her true husband, an attachment sparked by a childhood curiosity and nurtured with daily conversations and care for the idol. This devotion dista...

A Journey Called PrAja

Love is a relationship based on trust and understanding.  It is also a bond that is made up there. People often ask, "Why them?" I end up telling them some folklore. I end up telling them about how she actually was his shadow in the forests, in bad times. Because love passes all its tests in the worst times when you don't give up on each other. So, here's to My Pratap and His Ajabdeh! Ps. This is about the show Bharat Ka Veer Putra Maharana Pratap on Sony by Contilloe Starring Faisal Khan, Roshni Walia, Sharad Malhotra and Rachana Parulkar. This is NOT their real story. The show aired from 2013 to 2015. Ajabdeh, the simple, strong yet gentle samantputri, was starstruck seeing the down-to-earth Kunwar Pratap, the crown prince of Mewar. She was clueless that he held the key to her heart, her lost mala that destiny had chosen him for.  Na na na na na Chan Chan Chan Chan na na na na! A comedy of errors followed, as she threw the pail of water on him, fumbled at his presen...

The Annals of Rajputana

Col. James Todd’s Annals and Antiquities of Rajasthan describes Rajputana through History, Geography, Mythology, Folklore, Veer Gathas, Traditions, Cultures, Heritage, Rules, Valour and its people. However, one must remember that he was commissioned to write the narrative and his resources are not based on historical evidence. However, it is worth a read and very interesting. The following excerpts are from his book. Please take note that Todd's accounts are based on hearsay, stories, and commissioned by royals and hence aren't treated as historically accurate. However, his book is important as it is the first English-language book to have extensive work done on Rajputana. Rajputs are commonly believed to be people from Rajasthan; however, their branches have spread far and wide into Punjab, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Maharashtra and even parts of Bengal. The initial origination-based clans/tribes had been subdivided first in the book Prithvirajraso by Chand Bardai; howev...

The Reva Cries

Roopmati had watched the troops leave. She had stood behind the chief queen as she traditionally bid goodbye to her sons. She had waited for the Sultan to come to her. He did. He was confident that the sudden advancement of Akbar’s foster brother Adham Khan could be curbed. It was not war, just precaution. He reassured her. Malwa would never bow to the Timurids. And he would not let anything happen to her. To Her. Roopmati felt suffocated by her husband’s affectionate hug. She felt trapped in the scrutinising eyes of all the people in the palace. Angry, blaming eyes. She tried to pace herself and sing, but her voice cracked in fear. Her melody was drowned in tears. Every evening, a messenger would come to the chief queen with the news of war. Roopmati was kept in the darkness. She was not told about anything. She knew the rumours. She was a witch. A temptress who caused doom to the Sultan of Malwa. She was a spy of the enemy planted in his life to destroy him. She wondered if he came b...